PS

Penny Schmidt

Mediator

“Insurance Mediator”

Jacksonville, Florida
34+Years Exp

Core Practice Areas

8 Verticals
✓Elder Law & Care Disputes
✓Commercial Contracts
✓Personal Injury Claims
✓Product Liability
✓Insurance Coverage Disputes
✓Construction Disputes
✓Foreclosure Mediation
✓Bankruptcy Adversary Proceedings
✓Certified Neutral
✓Court-Approved ADR

About & Mediation Philosophy

Neutral Profile

Penny W. Schmidt received her undergraduate degree from the University of Florida and graduated with Honors from St. Thomas College of Law. She was admitted to the Florida Bar in 1992 and is a Florida Supreme Court qualified Arbitrator. She has also served as a Special Master and an Umpire. Prior to becoming a full-time mediator, she was a full-time civil litigator for thirty years. She began her legal career in Fort Myers where she worked as an Associate Attorney with the law firm of Fuller & Minor, P.A., later becoming a partner in the law firm of Minor & Schmidt, P.A. In 1997, she and her husband relocated to the Jacksonville area where she continued her legal career and was a long-time partner in the law firm of Schutt, Schmidt & Noey. Penny has been a Martindale-Hubbell AV Rated partner since 1997. She is a member of the Florida Bar and the U.S. District Court, Middle District of Florida. She is a member of the Jacksonville Bar Association and the Jacksonville Women’s Lawyer’s Association. She is the current Vice-Chair, and former Chairperson, of the Alternative Dispute Resolution section of the Jacksonville Bar Association as well as a member of the Alternative Dispute Resolution section of the Florida Bar. Penny is also a member of the National Academy of Distinguished Neutrals, Florida Academy of Professional Mediators and the Florida Circuit-Civil Mediators Society. She is a Volunteer Mediator and Arbitrator for the Florida Bar Grievance Mediation and Fee Arbitration Program. In addition, Penny served as an adjunct professor for over a decade at Florida Coastal School of Law, where she taught, among other things, Alternative Dispute Resolution to future lawyers. She has lectured to various professional organizations on a variety of mediation-related topics. Her civil litigation experience has been in the areas of Personal Injury/Wrongful Death, Trucking Litigation, Insurance Coverage Disputes, Complex Commercial and Construction Defect Litigation, Contract/Business Litigation and Appellate law. Commitment to positive mediation and arbitration outcomes forms the cornerstone of her professional practice. Personal attention to detail ensures the participants’ respect and successful problem resolution. As a mediator, she describes her style as “firm and direct, but engaged and creative.”

Credentials & Institutional Standing

Primary Verifications

License

Florida Supreme Court Certified Circuit Court Mediator

Education

St. Thomas College of Law

J.D. · Law

Class of 1992

University of Florida

B.A.

Work History

5 Positions

Partner

Schutt, Schmidt & Noey

1997 – Present

Long-time partner in Jacksonville area firm.

Full-time Civil Litigator

Various Firms

1992 – 2022

Practiced for thirty years prior to becoming a full-time mediator.

Partner

Minor & Schmidt, P.A.

Fort Myers

Associate Attorney

Fuller & Minor, P.A.

Fort Myers

Adjunct Professor

Florida Coastal School of Law

Taught Alternative Dispute Resolution to future lawyers for over a decade.

Honors & Recognition

1 Honor

AV Rated

Martindale-Hubbell

1997

AV Rated partner since 1997

Fees & Availability

Rate Schedule

Standard rates. Contact for custom arrangements.

No rate information on file.

—

Hourly rate

—

Minimum fee

October 2026LIVE
Mo
Tu
We
Th
Fr
Sa
Su
28
29
30
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
1
Avail
Booked
On Hold
Half Day

Book an Appointment

With Penny Schmidt

Next available

No upcoming availability

ADR actions

Questions? Email Case Manager

Is this your profile? Claiming it lets you edit your details, set rates, and accept bookings.

More Mediators Like This

Personal Injury ClaimsMotor Vehicle AccidentsMedical Malpractice Claims